Federal Government

BAAJA permitting bill could lock in seabed mining leases near the territories, critics say

By William-Jose Velez GonzalezComment

pasquines.us/2026/11/18/baaja-permitting-bill-territories-seabed-mining-tribal-nations/

Senators during the introduction of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act.
Senators during the introduction of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act.Image credit: Office of Senator Martin Heinrich (D) of New Mexico

The United States Senate voted 70 to 27 on November 16, 2026, to end debate on a revised version of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), clearing the way for a final vote as early as this week. The bill would rewrite how federal agencies review and approve projects across the country, and environmental lawyers representing groups in American Samoa and the Northern Mariana Islands warn that one provision could make it far harder for a future administration to undo the seabed mining leases the federal government is preparing to sell off both territories.

S 5653 was introduced on September 30 by Senator Shelley Moore Capito (R) of West Virginia, Senator Mike Lee (R) of Utah, Senator Sheldon Whitehouse (D) of Rhode Island, and Senator Martin Heinrich (D) of New Mexico. Its nearly 500 pages would change the National Environmental Policy Act, the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act, and the National Historic Preservation Act, the Honolulu Star-Advertiser reported, and would also speed approvals for power lines and pipelines and require data centers to pay for the grid upgrades they need, according to Inside Climate News. “I urge the swift passage of BAAJA to make life more affordable for American families,” Capito said when the sponsors released a revised version on November 7.

The territories have no senators to vote on it. If the bill reaches the US House of Representatives, their five members there can vote in committee but not on final passage.

Leases that would be hard to take back

The provision at the center of those warnings is Section 1401, labeled “project certainty.” As introduced, it would bar federal agencies from revoking, suspending, or altering a federal permit or authorization except in limited cases, such as a court order, a permit violation, fraud, a request from the permit holder, or certain threats to life, property, national security, or defense, according to the Congressional Research Service. Plaintiffs who win a lawsuit to enforce the section could recover 25% to 50% of total project costs from the Judgment Fund, a permanent federal appropriation.

Earthjustice, the environmental law organization representing plaintiffs in lawsuits over planned lease sales off American Samoa and the Northern Mariana Islands, argues that the provision would cover those leases. Section 1401 “will effectively lock in this administration’s decisions, whether good or bad,” Earthjustice legislative director Addie Haughey wrote on November 5. Once leases exist, she wrote, the bill “could block a future administration from reversing the leases or even adding environmentally protective conditions to them, regardless of the science or new policies to protect affected communities.”

On November 16, a federal judge in Honolulu ruled that the United States National Marine Fisheries Service violated the Endangered Species Act when it approved the first such sale, scheduled for November 19 off American Samoa. A second sale off the Northern Mariana Islands is set for December 16, with its closest lease area about 47 miles from Guam. Federal officials say a lease authorizes only preliminary work, such as mapping and sampling, and that any mining would need a separate plan and environmental review. Governor Lou Leon Guerrero (D) of Guam asked the US Department of the Interior’s Marine Minerals Administration in an October 20 letter to pause the Marianas sale until Guam has a meaningful say.

The November 7 revision changed parts of Section 1401. It added “human health, the environment” to the harms that would allow an agency to alter a permit, but only to prevent “immediate, specific, urgent, substantial, and proximate harm or damage,” and clarified that agencies could act in response to court decisions, Earthjustice wrote in its analysis of the changes. The group said the revision still leaves the “forever permits” issue unfixed.

PermittingWhen an agency could still change a permitSection 1401 would bar agencies from revoking, suspending, or altering federal permits effective on or after September 16, 2026, except in five cases. Compare the bill as introduced with the November 7 revision.
  1. CourtsA court orders the agency to act.Exception
  2. ViolationsThe permit holder materially breached its permit “or otherwise violated applicable law.”Exception
  3. FraudThe permit was obtained “through fraud, intentional concealment, or material misrepresentation.”Exception
  4. HarmActing is “necessary to prevent specific, urgent, substantial, and proximate harm or damage to life, property, national security, or defense,” based on new, previously unavailable information.Exception
  5. RequestsThe permit holder asks for the change.Exception

Plaintiffs who win a lawsuit to enforce Section 1401 could recover 25% to 50% of total project costs from the Judgment Fund.

SourcesCongressional Research ServiceEarthjustice

Species reviews in the territories

The bill’s Endangered Species Act changes would also reach the territories, which the act already counts as states. The current definition lists Puerto Rico, American Samoa, the US Virgin Islands, Guam, and the Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands. BAAJA would replace that last entry with the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands, a change the Congressional Research Service said would “reflect changes in the status” of the Northern Mariana Islands.

The bill would shorten the deadline for formal consultations, in which wildlife agencies review projects that could harm protected species, from 90 days to 60 days. It would create a program allowing states to take over consultations now conducted by the United States Fish and Wildlife Service if they can show the financial, personnel, and legal resources to do so. It would also require anyone challenging a biological opinion to file in the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit within 150 days. Under current law, such opinions can be challenged in federal district courts within six years. Earthjustice said the November 7 revision made “no substantial improvements” to the bill’s Endangered Species Act provisions.

Endangered Species ActHow species reviews would changeThe act counts the territories as states, so these changes would reach them too. Switch between current law and the bill to compare consultations and challenges to biological opinions.
  1. Consultation deadline90 days to conclude formal consultation
  2. ExtensionsUp to 150 days with only a written explanation
  3. Who consultsFederal wildlife agencies
  4. Court for challengesFederal district courts
  5. Deadline for challengesSix years
  6. Territories counted as statesPuerto Rico, American Samoa, the US Virgin Islands, Guam, and the Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands

The Congressional Research Service said swapping in the Northern Mariana Islands would reflect changes in its status.

SourcesCongressional Research ServiceLegal Information InstituteEarthjustice

Tribal nations and Native Hawaiians

Much of the criticism has come from environmental and tribal groups. As introduced, the bill would rewrite Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, which requires federal agencies to weigh effects on historic properties, by narrowing the projects subject to review, defining which effects count as “adverse,” setting deadlines, limiting judicial review, and limiting when agencies must consult state and tribal historic preservation officers, according to the Congressional Research Service.

Eleven tribal organizations, including the National Congress of American Indians, the Native American Rights Fund, and the All Pueblo Council of Governors, asked Congress on November 8 to hold the bill until the next Congress or remove its historic preservation title. “Tribal sovereignty, meaningful consultation, and the protection of sacred places are not negotiable,” they wrote. National Congress of American Indians President Mark Macarro said, “This bill is rotten from the inside and there is no fixing the rot.”

The November 7 revision dropped a section saying agencies “may consult” with tribal nations and a provision that would have narrowed which sites qualify as properties of traditional religious or cultural importance, Earthjustice wrote, but the group said the core problems remain. “I’ve worked hard to incorporate the feedback we’ve heard from Tribes and New Mexicans into this Substitute Amendment,” Heinrich said. The bill would also let tribes grant rights-of-way across their lands without approval from the Secretary of the Interior if their own regulations are approved, and would authorize $200 million a year for the Historic Preservation Fund and $20 million a year for a competitive grant program for tribal historic preservation officers.

The same historic preservation law requires agencies to consult Native Hawaiian organizations, and advocates in Hawaii have raised similar concerns. Senator Mazie Hirono (D) of Hawaii voted against advancing the bill on November 9, while Senator Brian Schatz (D) of Hawaii voted for it, the Star-Advertiser reported. “We need impacted communities to be consulted earlier,” said Davis Price, a senior domestic policy strategist at NDN Collective. Senator Ben Ray Luján (D) of New Mexico was among 27 Democrats who voted against ending debate on November 16.

A race against the calendar

The sponsors want the bill passed before Democrats take control of both chambers on January 3, 2027. If the US Senate approves it, it would go to the Republican-led US House. US House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D) of New York wants changes, Inside Climate News reported, and Representative Jared Huffman (D) of California, the top Democrat on the US House Committee on Natural Resources, has urged the US Senate to wait and revisit the bill in the next Congress, when Democrats will have more leverage. The American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations has endorsed the bill as a “critical first step towards meeting the moment on affordability, jobs, and environment,” while former Vice President Al Gore (D) called passing it a “serious mistake.”

PermittingThe bill and the lease salesKey dates for BAAJA and the seabed lease sales planned off American Samoa and the Marianas. Filter by track.

  1. BAAJA

    Senator Shelley Moore Capito introduced S 5653 with Senators Martin Heinrich, Mike Lee, and Sheldon Whitehouse.

  2. Seabed leases

    Governor Lou Leon Guerrero asked the Marine Minerals Administration to pause the Marianas sale.

  3. Both

    Earthjustice’s Addie Haughey wrote that Section 1401 would lock the administration’s seabed mining authorizations in place.

  4. BAAJA

    The sponsors released a revised version of the bill.

  5. BAAJA

    Eleven tribal organizations asked Congress to hold the bill until the next Congress.

  6. BAAJA

    The US Senate voted 73 to 25 to advance the bill. Senator Mazie Hirono voted no, and Senator Brian Schatz voted yes.

  7. BAAJA

    The US Senate voted 70 to 27 to end debate on the revised version.

  8. Seabed leases

    A federal judge ruled that the National Marine Fisheries Service violated the Endangered Species Act in approving the American Samoa sale.

  9. ScheduledSeabed leases

    The American Samoa lease sale is scheduled.

  10. PlannedSeabed leases

    The Marine Minerals Administration plans the Marianas lease sale.

  11. ScheduledBAAJA

    Democrats take control of Congress.

SourcesCongressional Research ServiceUS Senate Committee on Environment and Public WorksNational Congress of American IndiansHonolulu Star-AdvertiserSource New MexicoCourt rulingEarthjusticeSamoa NewsPasquines

At a glance

President
Donald Trump (R)
Puerto Rico
Resident Commissioner
Pablo José Hernández Rivera (PDP, D)
Guam
Delegate
James Moylan (R)
United States Virgin Islands
Delegate
Stacey Plaskett (D)
American Samoa
Delegate
Amata Coleman Radewagen (R)
Northern Mariana Islands
Delegate
Kimberlyn King-Hinds (R)
US senators
None
US House floor vote
No
US House committee vote
Yes
US House committee
Natural Resources
US Senate committee
Energy and Natural Resources
Interior Department
Office of Insular Affairs

NewsMatch

Your donation,matched twice

Through December 31, NewsMatch and its Philanthropic Access Fund match the first $2,500 we raise twice.

Donate now

Your donations help us publish

Make a tax-deductible contribution today.

Donate now

About the author

William-Jose Velez Gonzalez

William-Jose Velez Gonzalez

William-José Vélez González is a native from Mayagüez, Puerto Rico, and a graduate from Florida International University in biomedical engineering, engineering management, and international relations. A designer with a strong interest in science, policy, and innovation, he previously served as the national executive vice president of the Puerto Rico Statehood Students Association. William-José lives in Washington, DC, where he works at the Children's National Research Institute and runs Opsin, a nonprofit design studio dedicated to making design more accessible. You can see him on Love is Blind as Lydia's brother. He is the founder and Editor in Chief of Pasquines.

All stories

Be the first to add context

Submit a Comment

Comment guidelines

This space is for adding context.

  • Stay on topic. Share what you know and how you know it.
  • Criticize ideas, not people. No personal attacks, slurs, threats or harassment.
  • Link a source for factual claims when you can. No spam or ads.
  • Use one name. Pseudonyms are fine, but pretending to be someone else isn’t.

Your first comment is reviewed before it appears. We remove comments that break these rules, and we block people who break them seriously or repeatedly. Replies to our Bluesky posts appear here too, under the same rules.

Questions, or want to report a comment?

Contact us

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share This