A federal judge in Honolulu ruled on November 16, 2026, that the United States National Marine Fisheries Service violated the Endangered Species Act when it signed off on the first deep-sea mining lease sale in the United States, an auction of seabed off American Samoa scheduled for November 19. Judge Jill Otake of the US District Court for the District of Hawaii found that the agency looked only at the preliminary surveys the leases would allow and “did not even attempt to consider the potential effects of post-leasing activities,” including exploration and mining.
Otake granted summary judgment to Fa‘asao Amerika Samoa and the Conservation Council for Hawai‘i, which sued on August 18 with lawyers from the environmental law organization Earthjustice, and vacated the agency’s Letter of Concurrence, the February 2026 finding that the sale was not likely to adversely affect protected species. She called the agency’s “cramped, expedited, informal consultation” apparently unprecedented for leasing on the outer continental shelf and described its error as “fundamental.” The government had asked her to leave the letter in place while the agency fixed it, but she wrote that the National Marine Fisheries Service “needs to do the bulk of its consultation duty for the first time.”
The order vacated the letter and did not include an injunction against the auction. Bloomberg Law reported that the administration may not legally proceed with auctioning the more than 31 million acres. As of November 17, the Marine Minerals Administration’s website still listed the sale for November 19.
What the leases would allow
The Marine Minerals Administration, the United States Department of the Interior agency that replaced the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management this year, plans to offer two lease areas of about 16.3 million and 15.2 million acres, with a minimum bid of $3 million each, for polymetallic nodules and ferromanganese crusts on the seafloor. The federal government opened the process in June 2025 in response to an unsolicited request from Impossible Metals Inc., an American mining company, according to the ruling, less than two months after President Donald Trump (R) signed Executive Order 14285 on offshore critical minerals.
A lease would at first allow only surveys, mapping, and limited sampling. Exploration, testing, and commercial mining would each require a separate plan, environmental review, and approval. Federal attorneys called the risk to protected species at the lease stage “virtually nonexistent,” while Secretary of the Interior Doug Burgum told G20 energy ministers on September 14 that seabed mining permits could be issued “within months.”
- Lease sale. Scheduled for November 19, 2026: two areas of about 16.3 million and 15.2 million acres, with a minimum bid of $3 million each, for polymetallic nodules and ferromanganese crust deposits.
- Preliminary activities. A lease allows only “bathymetric, geological, geophysical, mapping, and other surveys,” which may include collecting limited samples of the seabed, according to the ruling.
- Delineation. More detailed geophysical and geological exploration may occur under a Delineation Plan, which the agency must approve before the work begins.
- Testing. Testing needs its own plan, approved by the agency, before it can begin.
- Commercial mining. The Marine Minerals Administration says it will not authorize commercial mining without a Mining Plan, environmental and technical review, and consultations.
The fisheries service reviewed only the first two stages. The court said it had to consider the whole action, through commercial mining.
SourcesCourt ruling
Federal Register
Marine Minerals Administration
Otake found that the National Marine Fisheries Service had to weigh the effects of the entire action, which she described as deep-sea mining of the outer continental shelf near American Samoa. The area under review is home to several dozen species listed under the Endangered Species Act, including blue, fin, sei, and sperm whales; green, hawksbill, loggerhead, leatherback, and olive ridley sea turtles; oceanic whitetip and scalloped hammerhead sharks; giant manta rays; the chambered nautilus; and five species of coral, according to the ruling.
“This ruling is a win for communities in American Samoa, as well as the whales, sharks, and sea turtles who call the waters surrounding these islands home,” Earthjustice attorney Chris Eaton said. “American Samoans share a profound cultural and spiritual bond with the ocean, which Samoans have stewarded for thousands of years. We are relieved by this ruling,” said Seumalu Dr. Elora Raymond, a cofounder of Fa‘asao Amerika Samoa.
A territory with limited say
American Samoa’s elected leaders can comment on the sale, but the decision rests with federal officials. Delegate Aumua Amata Coleman Radewagen (R), who cannot vote on the final passage of bills in the US House of Representatives, said in July that her opposition to seabed mining had not changed. “I represent our people, and most of our people are opposed,” she said.
Governor Pulaali’i Nikolao Pula (R), who secured a longer comment period in 2025, focused his September 15 comments to federal regulators on conditions. He wrote that the lease “does not itself authorize commercial mining” and that “American Samoa supports maintaining this distinction,” and asked that any preliminary work be used for research and monitoring. “Tuna supports thousands of livelihoods directly and indirectly and remains central to American Samoa’s economic security,” he wrote. The Marine Minerals Administration recommended accepting his comments “with qualification,” according to an agency decision memo that quotes his letter.
In a statement dated November 16, the same day as the ruling, Pula welcomed the sale as “a historic moment for American Samoa and for our nation.” “Let me be clear: this is not approval to mine our ocean floor,” he said, calling it an opportunity “to learn what resources may exist, understand the environment in which they are found, and determine whether future development can occur responsibly.” He pointed to population decline, limited economic diversification, and the reduction of temporary federal funding. “We cannot afford to stand still while our economy continues to face serious challenges,” he said. The statement, which did not mention the ruling, also said his administration is exploring ways to position Pago Pago as a regional maritime and logistics hub for deep-sea minerals activities.
A second lawsuit, filed October 19, raises a broader question. Faleula o le Manu‘atele, a council of matai, or chiefs, from the Manu‘a Islands, joined the two groups in arguing that the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act does not authorize mineral leasing in US territories and that treaty requirements must be met before leasing can occur in American Samoa.
The Marianas are next
The ruling also bears on the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam, where the Marine Minerals Administration plans a second sale on December 16. In a footnote, Otake noted that the same lawyers represent plaintiffs in a similar case over that sale, filed on behalf of Our Common Wealth 670, PåganWatch, the Conservation Council for Hawai‘i, and the Center for Biological Diversity. They ask her to vacate an August 10 letter in which the National Marine Fisheries Service reached the same conclusion for the Marianas. “I imagine that we can anticipate a similar or like ruling in CNMI,” Earthjustice attorney Harley Broyles told The Guam Daily Post in October, though she added that she could not speak for the court. Earthjustice attorney David Henkin discussed what the American Samoa ruling means for the Marianas in an interview with Marianas Press.
Both governors in the Marianas have asked federal regulators to hold off on that sale. Governor Lou Leon Guerrero (D) of Guam asked the Marine Minerals Administration in an October 20 letter to pause it. Governor David M. Apatang (I) of the Northern Mariana Islands, who had declined to ask the US Department of the Interior for a pause, saying he wanted to see how the lawsuits were decided, encouraged federal officials in October 16 comments to pause the leasing process until the two cases in Hawaii are resolved, while also seeking revenue sharing and safeguards. Leon Guerrero has said Guam was not consulted before the federal government sought information on deep-sea mining in the region. “We are not a sovereign nation, so we have no control,” she said.
Delegate Kimberlyn King-Hinds (R) of the Northern Mariana Islands has introduced the Pacific Minerals Economic Security Act, which would send 50% of revenue from covered leases to eligible adjacent territorial governments, strengthen financial assurance and environmental bonding requirements, and expand notification and consultation requirements. “While I do not support or oppose seabed mining, we must recognize the nation’s strategic imperative to develop secure critical mineral supply chains,” she said, adding that the bill “would provide a crucial insurance policy for the Pacific territories that could be directly affected.”
- Both
President Donald Trump signed Executive Order 14285 on offshore critical minerals.
- American Samoa
Responding to an unsolicited request from Impossible Metals Inc., the federal government asked for information and interest in leasing off American Samoa.
- American Samoa
The comment period closed, extended at the request of Governor Pulaali’i Nikolao Pula.
- American Samoa
The National Marine Fisheries Service received the request to consult on the American Samoa sale.
- American Samoa
The fisheries service issued its Letter of Concurrence, finding the sale not likely to adversely affect protected species.
- Both
The US Department of the Interior began its transition to the Marine Minerals Administration.
- Marianas
The governors of Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands asked Congress for a moratorium on deep-sea mineral leasing in the Mariana region.
- American Samoa
Delegate Aumua Amata Coleman Radewagen said her position against seabed mining had not changed.
- Marianas
The fisheries service reached the same conclusion for the Marianas sale.
- Marianas
The federal government issued its notice proposing the Marianas sale and sent it only to the Northern Mariana Islands governor.
- American Samoa
Fa‘asao Amerika Samoa and the Conservation Council for Hawai‘i sued the fisheries service.
- Both
Secretary of the Interior Doug Burgum told G20 energy ministers that seabed mining permits could be issued “within months.”
- American Samoa
Pula sent his comments on the American Samoa sale to federal regulators.
- Marianas
Earthjustice asked the court to vacate the fisheries service’s Marianas letter.
- Marianas
Governor David M. Apatang encouraged federal officials to pause the leasing process until the court cases are resolved.
- American Samoa
Faleula o le Manu‘atele joined a second lawsuit arguing that federal law does not authorize mineral leasing in US territories.
- American Samoa
The final notice of the American Samoa sale was published in the Federal Register.
- Marianas
Governor Lou Leon Guerrero asked the Marine Minerals Administration to pause the Marianas sale.
- American Samoa
Judge Jill Otake heard arguments in the American Samoa case.
- American Samoa
Otake vacated the Letter of Concurrence. In a statement dated the same day, Pula welcomed the sale.
- ScheduledAmerican Samoa
The American Samoa lease sale is scheduled.
- PlannedMarianas
The Marine Minerals Administration plans the Marianas lease sale.
SourcesCourt ruling
Federal Register
US Department of the Interior
The Guam Daily Post
Samoa News
Isla Public Media
Earthjustice
American Samoa Government
Office of Delegate Radewagen
Pasquines
Be the first to add context