Puerto Rico

Why there’s controversy on the death toll after Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico, in context

By Devorah Levy-PearlmanComment

pasquines.us/2018/07/22/why-theres-controversy-on-the-death-toll-after-hurricane-maria-in-puerto-rico-in-context/

Memorial of shoes at the Capitol of Puerto Rico, representing those lost to Hurricane Maria. Photo credit: Proyecto 4645
Memorial of shoes at the Capitol of Puerto Rico, representing those lost to Hurricane Maria.Photo credit: Proyecto 4645

Why there’s controversy on the death toll after Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico, in context

by Jul 22, 2018Headlines, Puerto Rico0 comments

Recently, the New England Journal of Medicine released a shocking report based on new data found on the death toll caused by Hurricane Maria. The Harvard University study found that last September’s hurricane may have been the nation’s deadliest natural disaster in 100 years. Moreover, the report says, Maria caused at least $900 billion in damages, which impaired the effectiveness of existing health surveillance infrastructure. The lack of accurate methods to determine mortality rates led to a gross miscalculation of the hurricane’s deadly impact. Recent new investigations estimate as many as 4,600 “excess deaths” between the hurricane’s onset and the end of the 2017 calendar year. The new estimate poses a startling figure in contrast to the government’s initial count of 64.

These convoluted death counts in the hurricane’s aftermath may be best explained by two factors: first, inaccurate and inconsistent methods of calculation; and second, the lack of top-down transparency. One report last December, conducted by Puerto Rican demographer Alexis Santos and health scientist Jeffrey Howard, used the Puerto Rico Vital Statistics System to compare yearly average mortality rates with the ones reported in September and October of 2017. For these two months, they found a total of over 1,000 excess deaths, indicating an alarming inconsistency with previous estimates.

What remains fuzzy is a basis of classification for determining whether a case was caused directly, indirectly, or not at all by the storm. This requires a nitty-gritty analysis of case-by-case mortality and its connection to hurricane impact. For example, power outages and supply shortages cut hundreds, and possibly thousands off from accessible medical care. The Harvard survey found that “interruption of medical care was the primary cause of sustained high mortality rates in the months after the hurricane.”

What confuses matters is the difficulty of assessing to what degree hurricane-related complications may have led to an individual death. The convoluted data results from differing approximations and varying methodologies, which are bound to produce inconsistent numerical outcomes. How did the December estimate of 1,000 become refigured as 4,600? Presumably, the initial study used a stricter classification of what qualifies a case as directly hurricane-related. If we were to aggregate all deaths either directly or indirectly related to Hurricane Maria, we should assume to find the actual death toll to be closer to the 4,600 count than the initial 1,000 estimate.

Further compounding the numerical challenges posed to assessing Maria’s impact is the lack of government transparency from the islands. The Puerto Rican government initially withheld data of the actual mortality count. Puerto Rican governor Ricardo Rosselló responded to the controversy by contrasting researchers at George Washington University who compiled the numerical data. To the suspicion of many in the journalistic community, the report fell far behind its release schedule. Finally, on June 5, a superior court judge ordered the government to issue a detailed report on every reported death since Maria. The Health Department reported 1,397 deaths since the hurricane, after the Harvard report had already estimated over 4,000 storm-related casualties.

At a glance

Flag of Puerto RicoCoat of arms of Puerto Rico
Citizenship
US citizens
Capital
San Juan
Population
3.2 million
Land area
3,515 sq mi
President
Donald Trump (R)
Legislature
SenateNPP19 PDP5 PIP2 PD1 I1HouseNPP36 PDP13 PIP3 PD1
Resident Commissioner
Pablo José Hernández Rivera (PDP, D)
Presidential vote
No
Voting representation in Congress
No
Official website
www.pr.gov

NewsMatch

Your donation,matched twice

Through December 31, NewsMatch and its Philanthropic Access Fund match the first $2,500 we raise twice.

Donate now

Your donations help us publish

Make a tax-deductible contribution today.

Donate now

About the author

Devorah Levy-Pearlman

Devorah Levy-Pearlman

Passionate about generating creative solutions in working towards a more just world, Devorah combines a global, socially-conscious outlook with pop-culture savviness. She relies on her strong communicative skills to story-tell and convey traditionally complex messages in a more easily digestible way through her writing. Devorah's approach is founded on varied experience in community politics, editorial writing, and communications, standing at the unique intersection between contemporary social problems, formal institutions of government, and digital media. She is a former Puerto Rico Affairs Intern Correspondent at Pasquines.

All stories

Be the first to add context

Submit a Comment

Comment guidelines

This space is for adding context.

  • Stay on topic. Share what you know and how you know it.
  • Criticize ideas, not people. No personal attacks, slurs, threats or harassment.
  • Link a source for factual claims when you can. No spam or ads.
  • Use one name. Pseudonyms are fine, but pretending to be someone else isn’t.

Your first comment is reviewed before it appears. We remove comments that break these rules, and we block people who break them seriously or repeatedly. Replies to our Bluesky posts appear here too, under the same rules.

Questions, or want to report a comment?

Contact us

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share This