Courts

Federal Court rules American Samoans should be granted birthright citizenship, but some American Samoans disagree

By Fred EdwardsComment

pasquines.us/2019/12/17/federal-court-rules-american-samoans-should-be-granted-birthright-citizenship-but-some-american-samoans-disagree/

John Fitisemanu, an American Samoan and the lead plaintiff in a lawsuit against the United States seeking full U.S. citizenship, poses for a photo in Salt Lake City, Utah. Photo credit: Katrina Keil Youd / Equally American via AP
John Fitisemanu, an American Samoan and the lead plaintiff in a lawsuit against the United States seeking full U.S. citizenship, poses for a photo in Salt Lake City, Utah.Photo credit: Katrina Keil Youd / Equally American via AP

Federal Court rules American Samoans should be granted birthright citizenship, but some American Samoans disagree

by Dec 17, 2019Courts, Headlines0 comments

Last week the US District Court for the District of Utah made a landmark decision against the United States in favor of John Fitisemanu, an American Somoan living in Utah who wants American Samoans to be recognized as citizens upon birth. Because he was born in the unincorporated US territory of American Samoa, Fitisemanu was born a US national, not a US citizen. His US passport even makes that distinction painfully clear, reading in all caps, “THE BEARER IS A UNITED STATES NATIONAL AND NOT A UNITED STATES CITIZEN.”

As a US national, John is restricted from things that ordinary citizens can take for granted, such as voting. In ongoing litigation, he is arguing that those born in US territories are guaranteed automatic citizenship under the 14th Amendment to the US Constitution. For Congress to make second class citizens of those born in territories by giving them only “national” status, rather than full citizenship, is a violation of the 14th Amendment.  Judge Clark Waddoups, deciding the case in the court in Utah, agreed.

The 14th Amendment provides that “[a]ll persons born . . . in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States.” Fitisemanu wanted the court to rule that because American Samoa is a territory of the United States, it is in the United States, and thus this citizenship clause grants birthright citizenship to those born in American Samoa. However, this argument is an uphill battle, because of a Supreme Court case from 1901 which ruled that only incorporated territories enjoyed the full protections of the US Constitution.

What’s interesting in this case is that the American Samoa Government and the Delegate from American Samoa, Aumua Amata Coleman Radewagen (R), both intervened in the case, and they sided with the United States. They opposed Fitisemanu asking the court to “unilaterally impose US citizenship on all American Samoans,” and warned that traditional Samoan ways, such as their rights to self-determination, could be threatened by such a change in status. In effect, they argue that it is for the people of American Samoa to decide, not a court, and they draw on more than a century of legal precedent to refute John’s points.

Amata called the ruling “unwelcome and inappropriate.” Her sentiments are likely echoed by a significant portion of the population of the territory, as the ruling could endanger laws regarding land ownership, since they exclude non-Samoans. By extending citizenship to all American Samoans, equal protection issues arise.

Although Fitisemanu won at the district court level, the case is likely to be appealed according to the plaintiff’s attorney. This would give the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals a chance to review the legal question of whether or not territories are “in the United States” for the purposes of the 14th Amendment.

If the 10th Circuit affirms this decision, it would be contradictory to a similar case in 2016. The US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruled that the constitution does not grant citizenship to those born in American Samoa, and the Supreme Court declined to hear the appeal. If Fitisemanu’s case is ultimately appealed to the Supreme Court, the Justices will be more inclined to hear the case if there are contradictory decisions in the circuit courts. Until then, the ruling has been stayed pending appeal.

At a glance

Federal court
US District Court for the District of Puerto RicoArticle III, judges serve for life
Highest local court
Supreme Court of Puerto Rico
Federal court
District Court of GuamArticle IV, 10-year judicial terms
Highest local court
Supreme Court of Guam
Federal court
District Court of the Virgin IslandsArticle IV, 10-year judicial terms
Federal court
NoneFederal cases generally go to district courts in Hawaii or Washington, DC
Highest local court
High Court of American Samoa
Federal court
District Court for the Northern Mariana IslandsArticle IV, 10-year judicial terms

Article IV judges are appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate for 10-year terms. Select a court for its website.

NewsMatch

Your donation,matched twice

Through December 31, NewsMatch and its Philanthropic Access Fund match the first $2,500 we raise twice.

Donate now

Your donations help us publish

Make a tax-deductible contribution today.

Donate now

About the author

Fred Edwards

Fred Edwards

Fred is currently pursuing a law degree and a master of arts in international affairs at American University, where he founded and is currently the President of the Political Law Society. He earned his bachelor of science in managerial economics from George Mason University, and he remains involved there through his Masonic lodge which is affiliated with the school. Fred’s father was in the Air Force and worked in England for a time, giving Fred the unique opportunity to earn two high school diplomas, one English and one American. He is a Political Affairs Correspondent at Pasquines.

All stories

Be the first to add context

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. A Place in the US With No Covid-19? Look to American Samoa. | Pasquines - […] All in all, the apparent success of American Samoa is likely due to several factors, but this might be…

Submit a Comment

Comment guidelines

This space is for adding context.

  • Stay on topic. Share what you know and how you know it.
  • Criticize ideas, not people. No personal attacks, slurs, threats or harassment.
  • Link a source for factual claims when you can. No spam or ads.
  • Use one name. Pseudonyms are fine, but pretending to be someone else isn’t.

Your first comment is reviewed before it appears. We remove comments that break these rules, and we block people who break them seriously or repeatedly. Replies to our Bluesky posts appear here too, under the same rules.

Questions, or want to report a comment?

Contact us

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share This